Some properties whisper “move-in ready.” This one hollers “bring a truck, a plan, and a sense of humor” — and if it feels like you’ve seen it before, that’s just the déjà vu talking.
Tucked into the hills of rural Santa Margarita, this ±38.54-acre parcel is a rancher’s, builder’s, or dreamer’s blank canvas. Two wells and two — possibly three — ponds mean water appears to be on your side (we don’t really know the water situation), a rarity worth its weight in gold out here. The land carries a main house (currently not habitable — this is a project, not a punch list), a shop building for the tools and toys, a library/office space that hints at a former life of quiet afternoons, and an unpermitted apartment that adds bonus square footage and bonus paperwork in equal measure.
This is a court-ordered sale, offered strictly as-is, where-is. The seller and agents are working with limited knowledge of the property’s history and condition — no inspection reports are available, and any the buyer wants will be entirely their own to order, at their own expense. What you see (and what you don’t yet know) is genuinely what you get.
A few ground rules before you go wandering: this is emphatically not a drive-by. No one may enter the property at any time without first signing a release of liability — no exceptions, no peeking over the fence. And depending on the season, the road in can get rugged enough that a 4-wheel-drive vehicle isn’t a suggestion, it’s a requirement.
If you’ve been waiting for a property that rewards patience, sweat equity, and a good set of tires, this is it. Showings scheduled only after the waiver is signed and received by the listing agent. Ask your agent to review the additional terms and conditions in the agent remarks prior to requesting to visit the property.
Tucked into the hills of rural Santa Margarita, this ±38.54-acre parcel is a rancher’s, builder’s, or dreamer’s blank canvas. Two wells and two — possibly three — ponds mean water appears to be on your side (we don’t really know the water situation), a rarity worth its weight in gold out here. The land carries a main house (currently not habitable — this is a project, not a punch list), a shop building for the tools and toys, a library/office space that hints at a former life of quiet afternoons, and an unpermitted apartment that adds bonus square footage and bonus paperwork in equal measure.
This is a court-ordered sale, offered strictly as-is, where-is. The seller and agents are working with limited knowledge of the property’s history and condition — no inspection reports are available, and any the buyer wants will be entirely their own to order, at their own expense. What you see (and what you don’t yet know) is genuinely what you get.
A few ground rules before you go wandering: this is emphatically not a drive-by. No one may enter the property at any time without first signing a release of liability — no exceptions, no peeking over the fence. And depending on the season, the road in can get rugged enough that a 4-wheel-drive vehicle isn’t a suggestion, it’s a requirement.
If you’ve been waiting for a property that rewards patience, sweat equity, and a good set of tires, this is it. Showings scheduled only after the waiver is signed and received by the listing agent. Ask your agent to review the additional terms and conditions in the agent remarks prior to requesting to visit the property.
Property Details
Price:
$425,000
MLS #:
NS26176645
Status:
Pending
Beds:
2
Baths:
0
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
Santa Margarita Rural80
Neighborhood:
smrgsantamargarita
Listed Date:
Aug 12, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
1,654
Lot Size:
1,678,802 sqft / 38.54 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1960
See this Listing
Schools
School District:
Atascadero Unified
Interior
Cooling
SEE
Laundry Features
IN
Levels
A
Main Level Bathrooms
1
Main Level Bedrooms
2
Exterior
Common Walls
NCW
Community Features
RUR
View
PAS
Financial
Map
Community
- Address4169 Stagecoach Canyon Santa Margarita CA
- SubdivisionSanta Margarita Rural(80)
- CitySanta Margarita
- CountySan Luis Obispo
- Zip Code93453
Subdivisions in Santa Margarita
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Santa Margarita as of Sep 16, 2026
15
Single Family Listed
115
Avg DOM
397
Avg $ / SqFt
$785,773
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the Santa Margarita Rural(80) subdivision, 4169 Stagecoach Canyon Santa Margarita CA is a Single Family for sale in Santa Margarita, CA, 93453. It is listed for $425,000 and features 2 beds, 0 baths, and has approximately 1,654 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1960. The current price per square foot is $257. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Santa Margarita is $397. The average listing price for Single Family in Santa Margarita is $785,773.
Similar Listings Nearby
4169 Stagecoach Canyon
Santa Margarita, CA

